My flatmates are still being elusive. Sometimes I hear noises from their rooms and new dishes on the draining board, so I know they’re not dead.
But neither are they truly alive.
I watched The Patriot at the weekend. It’s not as bad as I’d been led to believe by the man on the street, although I admit this may have lowered the bar to such an extent that the film barely needed to shuffle to get over it.
It wasn’t quite as rabidly anti-British as people claim, that’s for sure. The antagonist, Colonel Tavington, played by a snarling, cold-eyed Jason Isaacs, is loosely based on a real historical figure with the bombastic name Banastre Tarleton, who did indeed lead a company of light dragoons during the Revolutionary War and did do some pretty nasty things such as burning houses and massacring prisoners. He never locked an entire village of men, women and children in a church and burned them to death, but this incarnation is a Hollywood villain, after all. Cut him some slack.
Furthermore, other British characters are not quite so evil. Most are even portrayed as decent and civilised, if suffering the natural flaw of all eighteenth-century Englishmen abroad: arrogance. Tom Wilkinson, for instance, who plays the British commander Cornwallis, repeatedly castigates Tavington for his barbaric conduct. “We serve the Crown,” he says, “and we must conduct ourselves accordingly. Surrending troops will be given quarter; these brutal tactics must stop!” Conversely, Mel Gibson’s guerillas commit a few war crimes of their own before they are reined in.

A big problem with the film is that it was directed by Roland Emmerich, the man behind such braindead blockbusters as Stargate, Independence Day, The Day After Tomorrow and 2012. He doesn’t really do subtlety. This isn’t a problem when the main villains happen to be aliens or natural disasters, but some people get tetchy when he bludgeons a historical period with his hammy fists. Ideally Emmerich would be allowed to direct the action sequences, but kept away from everything else.
A lesser problem is the writer, Robert Rodat, who also wrote Saving Private Ryan and is currently working on a movie adaptation of the online RPG World of Warcraft. He’s not that bad a writer, but some lines are like being poked in the ears with hot needles. For example:
Mel Gibson: May I sit with you?
Love Interest: It’s a free country. [Dramatic pause.] Or at least it will be.
Ouch. He also tiptoes around the slavery issue with impressive deftness. The hero, we learn early on, only employs freed blacks on his farm, not slaves. The redemption of the white man is symbolised by a minor character who is a bit racist to one black recruit, but then makes friends with him at the end, so everything is fine.
Black and white, united by their hatred of the British
One might also question why Tavington’s murderous dragoons are, but for a single officer, portrayed as English, when his real-life counterpart commanded a unit composed entirely of loyalist Americans. Presumably having Americans committing atrocities against other Americans during the Revolutionary War would have shattered the delicate mythology upon which the emotional impact of the film depends. (For a drama which seeks to enrich the myth of America's founding by exploring just such ambiguities, I'd recommend HBO's awesome miniseries John Adams.)
Emmerich wouldn't let Thomas Jefferson slouch like this, that's for damn sure
Yet I still enjoyed The Patriot, and having watched and enjoyed it, I’m almost tempted to revisit Braveheart. Although I suspect that it will only appear more moronic the second time round.




















